[Update at end]
A perfect Post-Modern state would be a state that exists in multiple realities. In one reality, it would be a struggling, potentially viable state struggling under the burden of oppression. Such a state would feature plucky but out-gunned Resistance fighters fighting for freedom. When its overpowering oppressor reacted with Nazi-like indiscriminate disproportion to attacks, the state would be devastated but its people would persevere. The freedom fighters would be toasted as heroes to much of the world for their fortitude and refusal to submit.
During and after the most recent incursion by Israel into Gaza, this was precisely the image that was projected by the international media; this is the Gaza seen by the overwhelming majority of Muslims in the world. It is the Gaza seen by most inhabitants of the MSM universe. Richard Landes linked to an article describing what happened when a confirmed believer in "Gaza" was confronted with the non-Post-Modern brick and mortar (and sand) Gaza inhabited by actual people, rather than actors in a Post-Modern morality play:
I'm a poet, an English Jew and a frequent visitor to Israel. Deeply disturbed by the reports of wanton slaughter and destruction during Operation Cast Lead, I felt I had to see for myself. I flew to Tel Aviv and on Wednesday, January 28, using my press card to cross the Erez checkpoint, I walked across the border into Gaza where I was met by my guide, a Palestinian journalist. He asked if I wanted to meet with Hamas officials. I explained that I'd come to bear witness to the damage and civilian suffering, not to talk politics.
What I saw was that there had been precision attacks made on all of Hamas' infrastructure. Does UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon criticize the surgical destruction of the explosives cache in the Imad Akhel Mosque, of the National Forces compound, of the Shi Jaya police station, of the Ministry of Prisoners? The Gazans I met weren't mourning the police state. Neither were they radicalized. As Hamas blackshirts menaced the street corners, I witnessed how passersby ignored them.
THERE WERE empty beds at Shifa Hospital and a threatening atmosphere. Hamas is reduced to wielding its unchallengeable authority from extensive air raid shelters which, together with the hospital, were built by Israel 30 years ago. Terrorized Gazans used doublespeak when they told me most of the alleged 5,500 wounded were being treated in Egypt and Jordan. They want it known that the figure is a lie, and showed me that the wounded weren't in Gaza. No evidence exists of their presence in foreign hospitals, or of how they might have gotten there.
Read the whole thing.
In reality, Gaza is a proto-state ruled by a gang of thugs whose animating philosophy consists of overt anti-Semitic genocide based on their reading of the Koran. Consider which description is closer to the reality on the ground in Gaza. Then consider that when even the Saudis understand that supporting Hamas in Gaza is effectively supporting an Iranian incursion against the West and the Sunni world, the Western (including American) approach to Hamastan is not only intellectually bankrupt and psychologically deluded, but also profoundly self-defeating:
Continue reading "Gaza, the Quintessential Post-Modern State" »
Recent Comments