Daily Blog Roll


  • Google

    WWW
    shrinkwrapped.blogs.com



Blog powered by TypePad
Member since 01/2005

Cluster Map

« The New York Times, Ethics, and the Supreme Court | Main | PC & Defects in Reality Testing: Part V »

August 06, 2005

A New York Times Mystery

Today,  Damien Cave, in the New York Times, wonders Where Are the War Heroes?    The reporter describes the incredible exploits of a few of our military men and women in Iraq; truly their behavior defines "heroism". 

ONE soldier fought off scores of elite Iraqi troops in a fierce defense of his outnumbered Army unit, saving dozens of American lives before he himself was killed. Another soldier helped lead a team that killed 27 insurgents who had ambushed her convoy. And then there was the marine who, after being shot, managed to tuck an enemy grenade under his stomach to save the men in his unit, dying in the process.

Cave is puzzled by the lack of attention paid to these heroes.  Yet his second paragraph is a marvel of rationalization and externalization.

Their names are Sgt. First Class Paul R. Smith, Sgt. Leigh Ann Hester and Sgt. Rafael Peralta. If you have never heard of them, even in a week when more than 20 marines were killed in Iraq by insurgents, that might be because the military, the White House and the culture at large have not publicized their actions with the zeal that was lavished on the heroes of World War I and World War II.

The emphasis is mine.  Can you tell what is missing in the mention of "the military, the White House, and the culture at large", that might have some ability to publicize heroism of this order?

The bias of the media is often overt, shown in their choice of headlines and the slanting of articles with carefully calibrated modifiers (conservatives are usually "far right" while the far left is usually depicted as moderate  and never called "far left"), and various other tricks of the trade; however, its most egregious bias is shown by its choice of what not to treat as news.  Thus, the MSM can avoid the Swiftboat charges until they had no choice but to mention them (because Kerry mentioned the charges and the loyal MSM then had to try to negate and undermine them).  The Times has still not addressed the Air America-Gloria Wise scandal, which seems like a big deal.  And how many investigative stories has the Times done on the UN Oil for Food scandal? 

If most Americans have never heard of Sgts. Smith, Hester, and Peralta, perhaps it is because the New York Times and the rest of the MSM have ignored the stories.  Those of us who surf the blogosphere, including the Milblogs, have had ample opportunities to read about and marvel at the exploits of these wonderful young men and women.  Unfortunately, most Americans still get their news from the MSM.

Cave offers some feeble explanations for the lack of awareness of the public of these men and women.

Many in the military are disheartened by the absence of an instantly recognizable war hero today, a deficiency with a complex cause: public opinion on the Iraq war is split, and drawing attention to it risks fueling opposition; the military is more reluctant than it was in the last century to promote the individual over the group; and the war itself is different, with fewer big battles and more and messier engagements involving smaller units of Americans. Then, too, there is a celebrity culture that seems skewed more to the victim than to the hero.

Who would use the heroic deaths of Sgts. Smith  and Peralta, or the courage of Sgt. Hester as weapons to use against the war?  Who would lead with the charge that using the deaths of Americans in battle would be shameful "politicizing the war" by the "far right" Bush administration?  Who would raise questions about a woman soldier killing so many Iraqis, perhaps including the innocent civilians who always seem to be found by the MSM when they want to undermine our prosecution of the war?  Who would print sad editorials concluding that the deaths of Peralta and Smith just show how wasteful it is for our young people to die in a misguided war?

If you guessed the New York Times would be in the forefront of those trying to discredit these heroes and use them against the administration, you would be absolutely correct.  I regret that I canceled my subscription to the Times two years ago... but only because I can not now cancel them again.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451b8f869e200d8342602fd53ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference A New York Times Mystery:

» The Real National Security Threat- Al Qaeda's Prop from Dr. Sanity
UPDATE II: ShrinkWrapped solves a NY Times "mystery". Actually it is only a mystery to the Times [Read More]

» The New York Times Disgusts Me from Hold The Mayo
The Times prints a story about the first Medal of Honor given in the War on Terror on page 13 and one of their writers has the gall to ask why there are no public heroes. [Read More]

» I'll tell you where the heroes are, but you won't report on them. . . from JasonColeman.com
Damien Cave of the New York times wonders, "Where Are the War Hero's?" Cave uses the piece to criticize the administration for not promoting the individual heroic deeds of the GWOT and suggests that the reason the military isn't applauding... [Read More]

» WHY? from Delftsman
To all those that ask WHY did my (insert military family connection here) have to die in Iraq/Afghanistan?; Mamamontezz has an answer that says it all....in a nutshell, it's because you raised your child correctly, or married a person who... [Read More]

» You Can't Find What You're Not Looking For from jaceonline
A New York Times story wonders why we're not hearing more about heroes of the Iraq War. This is like the Joker wondering why we don't hear more about Batman. Could it be because if there are brave people making noble sacrifices in Iraq, then everythi... [Read More]

» Maybe We Should Keep The Press Out Of This. from Just Some Poor Schmuck
Instapundit connects to the New York Times article "Where Are The Heroes" about the dearth of reporting on the heroes of the Iraq War. Damien Cave,the author of the article places the blame exactly where a good reporter (who wants... [Read More]

» New York Times' Damien Cave Finds 'Unknown' Heroes Hard to Explain? from The Blue State Conservatives
The New York Times' Damien Cave wonders in a Sunday article, Where Are the War Heroes? Wind of this stunning display of ignorant self-righteousness comes from Media Lies and Ranting Profs, who both do some heavy lifting in an attempt... [Read More]

Comments